Lieutenant
- 2020 Matt Gilbert
- 2019 Mark Skidmore
- 2018 Dennis Millner
- 2017 Mike Rummel
- 2016 Mark Skidmore
- 2014 Matt Gilbert
- 2013 Matt Gilbert
- 2012 Matt Gilbert
- 2011 Robert Baker
- 2010 Tyler Timmons
- 2009 Tyler Timmons
- 2008 Scott Veasey
- 2006 Scott Veasey
- 2005 Scott Veasey
- 2004 Robert Baker
- 2003 John Reppert
- 2002 Matt Warrington
- 2001 Chad Morris